NextDNS vs Pi-hole: Which DNS-Level Ad Blocker Should You Use?

Browser ad blockers only cover one browser. These two block ads, trackers, and threats for every device on your network at the DNS level, but they work very differently.

The NextDNS logo and dashboard promotional graphic
NextDNS's cloud DNS firewall dashboard. Image: NextDNS.

If you want ads and trackers blocked on every device on your network, your phone, your smart TV, your kid's tablet, all of it, a browser extension like uBlock Origin won't cut it. For that you need DNS-level blocking, and the two names that come up constantly are NextDNS and Pi-hole. The short answer: Pi-hole is free, self-hosted, and gives you full control if you're willing to run a server; NextDNS is a paid cloud service that works everywhere instantly, including on cellular networks, with no hardware required. Which one is right for you depends mostly on whether you want to run your own infrastructure.

Both tools work by intercepting DNS requests, the lookups your devices make to turn a domain name like doubleclick.net into an IP address, and refusing to resolve known ad, tracker, and malware domains. That blocks the request before any connection is even made, which is why DNS-level blocking stops ads and trackers in apps and smart-TV software that a browser extension like uBlock Origin or AdGuard can never reach.

Quick verdict: Want it to just work on your phone, laptop, and home Wi-Fi with zero hardware, and don't mind paying $1.99/month? Pick NextDNS. Have a Raspberry Pi, old PC, or NAS sitting around, want it completely free, and don't mind some setup and maintenance? Pick Pi-hole.

What NextDNS and Pi-hole actually are

NextDNS is a cloud-based DNS firewall. You don't install anything on your network; you point your devices' DNS settings (or a router) at NextDNS's servers, and it filters every query against its blocklists in real time, from one of 132 server locations worldwide, according to NextDNS. It bills itself as a full DNS firewall rather than just an ad blocker: it also blocks phishing and malware domains, cryptojacking scripts, DNS rebinding attacks, typosquatted domains, and newly registered domains often used in scam campaigns.

Pi-hole is free, open-source software you run yourself, on a Raspberry Pi, an old laptop, a virtual machine, a NAS, or in a Docker container. Once it's running, you point your router's DHCP settings at it (or Pi-hole can act as your DHCP server) so every device on the network automatically uses it for DNS. It works as a DNS sinkhole: it answers queries for domains on its blocklists with a non-routable address instead of the real one, stopping the ad or tracker before it loads.

Setup and ongoing maintenance

This is the biggest practical difference between the two. NextDNS setup takes a few minutes: create a free account, get your configuration ID, and either change the DNS servers in your router or install a small app/profile on each device that supports DNS-over-HTTPS or DNS-over-TLS. There's no hardware to maintain, no software to update, and no uptime to worry about beyond NextDNS's own servers.

Pi-hole, as a project you host yourself, is more involved. The official installer runs on common Linux distributions, or you can run Pi-hole in a Docker container. You're responsible for keeping the device powered on and connected, updating Pi-hole and its blocklists, and troubleshooting if your home internet, router, or the hardware running Pi-hole goes down, because if it does, DNS resolution for your whole network can go down with it unless you've configured a fallback resolver. Pi-hole's documentation covers this, and seasoned users typically run a backup DNS or a second Pi-hole instance for redundancy.

Pricing: free vs. paid

Pi-hole itself is free and open-source; the project funds development through donations and sponsorships rather than charging for the software. Your only real cost is whatever hardware you run it on, which for many people is a Raspberry Pi they already own or an always-on machine they're already running for something else.

NextDNS has a free tier, but it caps you at 300,000 DNS queries per month, after which it stops blocking (though it keeps resolving queries) until the next billing cycle. A typical household can burn through that limit quickly. The paid Pro tier removes the cap entirely for $1.99/month or $19.90/year, and covers unlimited devices and configurations. NextDNS also sells Business and Education tiers priced per 50 employees or per 250 students respectively, at $19.90/month or $199/year, aimed at organizations rather than individual households.

CategoryNextDNSPi-hole
HostingCloud (NextDNS's servers)Self-hosted (your hardware)
Setup difficultyLow; change DNS settings or install a profileModerate; install software, configure router/DHCP
PriceFree up to 300,000 queries/month; Pro $1.99/mo or $19.90/yr for unlimitedFree and open-source; hardware cost only
Works away from home networkYes, on cellular and public Wi-Fi via DNS-over-HTTPS/TLS profilesOnly with extra setup (VPN back to your network, e.g. WireGuard)
MaintenanceNone; NextDNS runs the infrastructureYou maintain uptime, updates, and backups
Security feed scope10+ categories: phishing, malware, cryptojacking, DNS rebinding, typosquatting, newly registered domains, Google Safe BrowsingBlocklist-based; scope depends on lists you add
Logging/privacy controlYou choose retention (1 hour to 2 years, or off) and storage region (US, EU, UK, Switzerland)Logs stay on your own hardware; you control retention entirely
Parental controlsBuilt-in category blocking, SafeSearch, YouTube Restricted Mode, time limitsPossible via group management and denylists, but less turnkey

Privacy and logging

With Pi-hole, your DNS query logs never leave your own network unless you choose to send them somewhere. You control retention entirely, and there's no third party involved in deciding how long your browsing-adjacent data is kept.

With NextDNS, your queries do pass through a third party's servers, which is the tradeoff for not hosting anything yourself. NextDNS lets you set log retention anywhere from one hour up to two years, or disable logging entirely, and lets you choose which region your logs are stored in: the US, EU, UK, or Switzerland. That's meaningfully more transparency and control than most commercial DNS resolvers offer, but it's still a cloud service you have to trust, compared to Pi-hole's logs never leaving your house.

Reliability and performance

Because NextDNS runs its own global network, described on its site as 132 server locations handling roughly 100 billion queries a month and blocking around 15 billion of them, it's built for the kind of uptime and low latency a commercial DNS provider needs to stay competitive. The tradeoff is that if NextDNS has an outage or you lose internet connectivity to its servers, your DNS resolution is affected too.

Pi-hole's reliability is entirely a function of your own setup. If the device running it stays online and you've configured sensible upstream DNS resolvers, it can be extremely fast since it caches answers locally. But a Pi-hole box that loses power, or a home internet outage, can take down DNS for every device on your network unless you've planned a fallback, something NextDNS users never have to think about.

Blocklists, allowlists, and customization

Pi-hole's blocking power comes entirely from blocklists you subscribe to; it ships with a sensible default list but the real strength of the project is that you can add any number of community-maintained lists, write your own regex-based rules, and manage allowlists and denylists per device or per group through its web dashboard. That flexibility is also the main maintenance burden: a badly chosen list can break a legitimate site, and you're the one who has to notice and fix it.

NextDNS takes a more curated approach. You pick from a set of popular blocklists in its dashboard (it supports well-known ones like OISD and AdGuard's lists alongside its own), toggle security categories on or off, and maintain your own custom allowlist and denylist, all through a web UI with no servers to patch. NextDNS also offers "Tracker Insights," which shows which companies are tracking you across the sites and apps you use, a feature Pi-hole's logs don't surface in the same packaged way, though the raw data is there if you want to dig for it yourself.

Family use and multi-device management

Both tools support unlimited devices, but they manage them differently. Pi-hole's dashboard lets you create client groups and assign different blocking rules to, say, a kid's tablet versus an adult's laptop, all enforced locally. NextDNS's parental controls are more turnkey: category blocking for categories like adult content, violence, and piracy, enforced SafeSearch and YouTube Restricted Mode, app and site blocking by name, and scheduled "Recreation Time" windows that can lock down non-essential domains during homework or bedtime hours. For families who want parental controls without configuring anything themselves, that polish is a real advantage of the cloud approach.

Router-level vs. device-level setup

Pi-hole is almost always deployed at the router level: once you point your network's DHCP at it, every device connected to that Wi-Fi or Ethernet network is covered automatically, with nothing to install on phones, laptops, or smart-TVs individually. The tradeoff is that it only protects devices while they're on that network; a phone that leaves the house and switches to cellular data gets no protection unless you've set up a VPN tunnel back home.

NextDNS can be deployed either way. You can point a router at it the same way you would Pi-hole, covering the whole network at once, or you can install a lightweight profile or app on individual devices that encrypts DNS over HTTPS or TLS and keeps working no matter what network that device joins, including cellular. That per-device option is the feature Pi-hole simply can't match without extra VPN infrastructure, and it's the main reason people choose NextDNS for phones and laptops that travel.

So which should you use?

If you want DNS-level ad and tracker blocking with the least effort and don't mind paying a couple of dollars a month, NextDNS is the easier recommendation, especially if you want the same protection on your phone over cellular data, not just at home. If you're comfortable running a small always-on device, want the strongest privacy guarantee of logs never leaving your house, and don't want a subscription, Pi-hole is the better fit. Plenty of advanced users actually run both: Pi-hole at home for free, local, zero-latency blocking, and a NextDNS profile on mobile devices for when they're off the home network. For a broader look at protecting your traffic beyond ad blocking, see our VPN vs. Tor comparison and our breakdown of Tailscale vs. WireGuard for secure remote access back to a home Pi-hole setup.

Common setup pitfalls

The most common Pi-hole complaint is a single point of failure: if the device running it loses power or crashes, every device on the network can lose DNS resolution until you fix it, so most guides recommend configuring a secondary upstream DNS server as a fallback, or running a second Pi-hole instance for redundancy. The other frequent issue is an overly aggressive blocklist breaking a site's login or checkout flow, which Pi-hole's per-domain allowlist is built to fix once you notice the breakage.

NextDNS users run into a different set of issues: some ISPs and routers lock DNS settings to their own servers, which can require switching to a DNS-over-HTTPS or DNS-over-TLS profile instead of a plain DNS server change, and heavy households can burn through the free tier's 300,000 monthly query cap faster than expected, especially with several streaming devices and smart-home gadgets making constant background requests. Both of those are solved by upgrading to the $1.99/month Pro tier.

What to do next

If you're new to DNS-level blocking and don't own spare hardware, start with NextDNS's free tier to see how it fits your household's query volume before deciding whether to upgrade to Pro. If you already have a Raspberry Pi or an always-on server, Pi-hole costs nothing but a bit of setup time and is worth trying first. Either way, you can also combine one of them with a VPN or Private Relay for additional encryption on top of DNS-level filtering.

Frequently asked questions

Is NextDNS free?

NextDNS has a free tier, but it caps you at 300,000 DNS queries per month; once you hit that limit it stops blocking until your next billing cycle. The unlimited Pro tier costs $1.99/month or $19.90/year.

Is Pi-hole really free?

Yes. Pi-hole is free and open-source software. The project is funded by donations and sponsorships rather than charging for the software itself; your only cost is the hardware you run it on.

Does Pi-hole work when I'm away from home?

Not by default. Pi-hole protects devices on your local network. To use it away from home you need to connect back to your network through a VPN, such as WireGuard, so your device's DNS queries route through Pi-hole.

Can I use NextDNS and Pi-hole together?

Yes. A common setup is running Pi-hole at home for free, zero-latency, local blocking, and using a NextDNS profile on phones and laptops for when they're on cellular data or other networks away from home.

Does DNS-level blocking replace a browser ad blocker?

Not entirely. DNS-level blocking like NextDNS or Pi-hole stops requests to known ad and tracker domains network-wide, including in apps, but it can't remove ad placeholders or do the fine-grained element hiding that a browser extension like uBlock Origin does within a web page.

Sources

More on DNS Ad Blocking →NextDNSPi-holeDNS Ad BlockingNetwork SecurityPrivacy
Sana Qureshi
Written bySana Qureshi

Sana Qureshi runs the security and privacy desk. She reports on actively exploited vulnerabilities, vendor patches and data breaches, and covers the password managers, VPNs and authentication tools readers use to protect themselves. Her alerts cite vendor advisories, CISA and the CVE record directly.

More from Security & Privacy

See all